Why willpower loses against the feed
Published Last updated
Everyone who scrolls more than they want to has tried the obvious thing: deciding not to. It works for a day or two, which is just long enough to make the failure feel personal.
It is not personal. The design of the situation explains most of it.
The moment is rigged
Look at when you reach for the feed. You are tired, you have just finished something, you are waiting for something, you are avoiding something. Almost nobody opens TikTok at their sharpest.
Now look at what you are deciding against. An app that is one tap away, that starts in under a second, that costs nothing, that has no natural end, and that is designed by people whose job is to make the next thing worth staying for.
Willpower is the part of this you can control least and are asked to supply most. Of course it loses.
What economists measured
In 2022 three economists published a randomized experiment and an economic model of social media use. Two results from it are worth knowing.
Self-control problems account for 31% of social media use. That is the model's estimate: about a third of the time people spend is time they would rather not have spent.
Letting people set limits on their own future screen time reduced their use substantially. The experiment gave people the option to cap their future use, and taking that option changed behaviour.
They also found that temporary incentives to use social media less had persistent effects, and that people are partly unaware of their own habit formation and self-control problems (American Economic Review 112(7), 2424–63, 2022).
That second point is the practical one, and it is not about resolve. The same person who cannot stop at 11pm will happily set a limit at 6pm. What changed is not the person; it is when the decision is made.
Deciding in advance versus deciding in the moment
This is the whole trick, and it shows up everywhere once you notice it.
- You can fail to resist a biscuit at 10pm and also not buy biscuits on Saturday.
- You can fail to get up for a run and also meet someone at 7am who will be waiting.
- You can fail to stop scrolling and also have the app locked before the evening starts.
In every pair, the second version is not more disciplined. It just moved the decision to an hour when it was easy, and made it stick.
The experiment above is one version of that. A limit that cannot be dismissed is another.
Why most limits still fail
Because they are not limits, they are suggestions.
Apple's Screen Time lets you set an app limit, and when you hit it you get a screen with a button that dismisses it. After a week, pressing that button is as automatic as opening the app was. The limit is still there; it just stopped being a limit.
A limit works when, at the moment you meet it, there is nothing to tap. Everything else is a reminder, which is useful for a while and then is not. Our guide on setting an app limit you cannot ignore goes through the options on an iPhone, including the ones built in.
What to set up instead
Make the decision once a week, not forty times a day. Choose which apps are locked and when, on a Sunday, and leave it alone.
Put distance between you and the tap. Apps off the home screen, notifications off, charger in another room. None of these is dramatic. Together they move the moment from "one tap" to "several deliberate steps", which is where your judgement comes back.
Give the moment something else. Removing the feed leaves a gap at exactly the time of day you are least inventive. Decide in advance what goes in it: what to do instead of doomscrolling has the step-by-step version.
Expect to want it anyway. The goal is not to stop wanting to scroll. It is for wanting it to stop being enough to get it.
The idea behind Unrot
This post is the closest to what our app does, so here it is plainly.
Unrot is an iPhone app that locks the apps you choose. They are not blocked at a time of day and not for a session you start: they are locked until you spend coins, and coins come from completing a habit — a walk, twenty minutes of reading, a workout, a photo of the thing you said you would do.
Two things follow from that. The decision is made when you set it up, not when you are tired. And the only route through is doing something you had already decided was worth more than the hour. There is no button that dismisses it, because the button is the problem.
More on the mechanics: how Unrot works.
Sources
- Allcott, H., Gentzkow, M., & Song, L., "Digital Addiction", American Economic Review 112(7), 2424–63, 2022. Randomized experiment with an estimated model; self-control problems account for 31% of social media use, limit-setting substantially reduced use, and temporary incentives had persistent effects.
Related pages
Frequently asked questions
Why can't I control my phone use?
Because the decision happens at the worst moment: tired, bored, with the app one tap away. A choice you make in advance does not have to survive that moment.
How much of social media use is a self-control problem?
In a randomized experiment modelled by economists, self-control problems accounted for 31% of social media use. The same work found that letting people set limits on their own future use reduced it substantially.
Do app limits work?
They work when they cannot be dismissed with a tap. Apple's Screen Time limits can be ignored with a button, which is why many people stop noticing them.
Is willpower useless then?
No, but it is a bad thing to spend every evening. Use it once, to set something up, instead of every time you reach for your phone.